Corn Pudding from Hilda Crockett's Chesapeake House (2024)

Creamy & comforting Corn Pudding, straight from Hilda Crockett's Chesapeake House, Tangier Island, Virginia. It's so easy to make, and sooo good!

Last summer my husband and I took a trip to Tangier Island, Virginia~ a small historic island in the middle of the Chesapeake Bay, 12 miles off shore and accessible only by boat or small airplane. So why am I writing about a summer trip now, in the Fall? Because I think this corn pudding dish we discovered while there is a perfect Thanksgiving side! With Thanksgiving fast approaching, I figured now was a great time to share this find.

But before we get to the scrumptious corn pudding, let me tell you a little about this unique and interesting island.

Approximately500 people make 0.2 square-mile Tangier Island their home. There are no cars (well,we saw two), no city sounds, no traffic lights, no rushing around, no chain restaurants. There are narrow quaint streets, lotsof marshes and seagrass, the beautiful sounds of boat engines and waves, a laid-back atmosphere, bicycles and golf carts for transportation, and crabs. Lots of tasty crabs. This quiet island is certainly not for everyone. My husband and I? - we loved it.

To be honest, Mark was immediately comfortable on Tangier, butI was a bit apprehensive at first. It took me a couple of days to settle into the island way. But Tangier certainly grew on me. It's not easy to describe the island, it's people, theTangier way of life, orexactly why we loved it. And I'm sure I won't even come close to doingit justice. Buthere area few snippets of Tangier life to give a tiny glimpse into this unique place.

Water & Quiet:
I think these pictures speak for themselves!

The beach ... in JULY!! If you want a private beach, here you go.

How beautiful is that? And a beach in July with nobody on it? Not many other places you can find that!

There's an airport on the island, accessible for small aircraft - it's quiet, too. Have you ever walked to the beach on an airstrip? Well, Mark and I have! That's how quiet the airport is. You simply need just look up in the sky before embarking on your walk to the beach. All clear? Then go ahead!

Our feet on the airstrip, walking back from the beach

Super-Fresh Crab:
Crabbing is the way of life on Tangier. In fact, Tangier is referred toas the soft shell crab capital of theworld. I had crab in some form or another for every meal while we were on Tangier. I love crab, and could eat it every day. I swear I could.

Thanks to Ooker, a local waterman and mayor of Tangier, we had the pleasure of visiting a crab shack and learning about the soft shell crabbing industry. From what I could tell, being a waterman is tough work, but also a tradition and labor of love for the residents of Tangier.

Crab shacks

Tourism:
During the summer,a couple offerry boats come to the island each day, allowing passengers to explore the island. Thetiny streets would bustlewith activity for a few hours each mid-day while these short-timeguests visited the island offerings.

Ferry coming in

Golf carts (one of the island's modes of transportation) would buzz visitors around ...

Island transportation

... and then the visitors would board back on their ferry boats and the streets would return to their 'normal' quiet.

Quiet street

Unique Dialect:
One of the most intriguing experiences on Tangier Island was hearing the unusual accent of the residents. Because of centuries of relative isolation, the islanders still speak in a unique island way that is similar to the speech spoken when Tangier was settled in 1686.The accentis still strong enough that some peopleare not able to understand everything that is said. I was one of these people. After several days on Tangier I was getting much better at conversing with the residents, but I admit that I had to concentrate. Many videos and documentaries have been made about the island, highlighting the unique island dialect, if you'd like to learn more.

Hilda Crockett's Chesapeake House:
And, finally, let's talk about Hilda Crockett's Chesapeake House, one of the three inns on the island, and the only inn also serving lunch and dinner. Family-style. With lots of food. Yummy home-cooking kinda food.

John Crockett settledTangier island in 1686. Many of the inhabitants still have the surname Crockett - and I can only assume Hilda Crockett was descended from the island founder. Hilda Crockett's Chesapeake House was started in 1939 by Hilda herself, and is now run by Denny and Glenna Crockett.

Thankfully, Hilda Crockett's Chesapeake House is willing to share it's recipes. And, as you know if you're a frequent reader of this blog, I am a totally-obsessed recipe collector! So, naturally, I gathered all the recipes I could while visiting Tangier. I've made many of the dishes I learned about during our visit, and Hilda Crockett's Corn Pudding is one of my favorites. I hope you enjoy it's smooth-and-creamy, sweet-and-tasty deliciousness as much as I do! Thank you to Hilda and her familyfor graciously sharing her wonderfully scrumptious recipe.

(Visit Wikipedia to read more about Tangier Island.)

Check out these other super tasty corn dishes:

Thank you for stopping by The Kitchen is My Playground. We'd love to have you back soon!

You might also like these other scrumptious side dish recipes: